Main
United States
Shelter Island
logo
Select currency
  • ARS
    Argentina, Peso
  • AUD
    Australian dollar
  • BRL
    Brazilian real
  • CAD
    Canadian dollar
  • CNY
    Chinese yuan
  • CZK
    Czech koruna
  • DKK
    Danish krone
  • EUR
    Euro
  • HKD
    Hong Kong dollar
  • ILS
    Israeli new sheqel
  • JPY
    Japanese yen
  • MYR
    Malaysian ringgit
  • NZD
    New Zealand dollar
  • NOK
    Norwegian krone
  • PLN
    Polish zloty
  • GBP
    Pound sterling
  • RON
    Romanian leu
  • RUB
    Russian ruble
  • SAR
    Saudi riyal
  • SGD
    Singapore dollar
  • ZAR
    South African rand
  • KRW
    South Korean won
  • SEK
    Swedish krona
  • CHF
    Swiss franc
  • THB
    Thai baht
  • TRY
    Turkish lira
  • USD
    U.S. dollar
  • UAH
    Ukrainian hryvnia
My bookings
Contact us
Read our FAQs

Seaview Hotels in Shelter Island - Compare & Book Today

Only Handpicked and Verified Accommodations for Your Stay in Shelter Island, United States

Check-in
30May
Check-out
31May
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Shelter Island is home to Crescent Beach, Sunset Beach, and the Shelter Island Country Club, offering stunning coastal views and recreational activities. You can explore the Mashomack Preserve for hiking and nature watching or dine at the iconic Vine Street Café. The hotels around here are chosen for their fantastic seafront locations and unique offers, from cozy inns with ocean views to luxury resorts featuring spa services. This site provides a curated selection of hotels in Shelter Island, ensuring you find a perfect stay. Remember to book ahead during summer and check for local ferry schedules to move around easily.
Filter by:
More +
Star rating
Guest rating
Accommodation type
Price per night
Popular landmarks
Amenities
Services
1-2 out of 2
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
The Pridwin Hotel
8.6
Great
The Pridwin Hotel
1.9 mi from City Centre
FromUS$ 334 /nightSelect
Sunset Beach
7.8
Very good
Sunset Beach
1.5 mi from City Centre
FromUS$ 596 /nightSelect

Price range for hotels in Shelter Island

A world of accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly stays to luxurious retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's dream vacation.

⬆️ The highest price
USD 596
⬇️ The lowest price
USD 334
💸 Average price for
4-star hotels
USD 442

Best hotels in Shelter Island

Based on guest reviews over the last 12 months

Coastal Charm Retreat:
The Pridwin Hotel
Secluded Sunset Getaway:
Sunset Beach

FAQs about hotels in Shelter Island

We hope that the answers to these questions will help you plan your trip

Which hotels in Shelter Island offer the best views?
The Pridwin Hotel offers stunning waterfront views of Crescent Beach, while Sunset Beach provides picturesque sunsets over the harbor.
Are there family-friendly hotel options in Shelter Island?
Both The Pridwin Hotel and Sunset Beach are family-friendly, but The Pridwin Hotel is particularly noted for its spacious accommodations and activities for children.
Which hotel is best for couples on a romantic getaway?
Sunset Beach is favored by couples seeking a romantic atmosphere with its beachfront setting, sunset views, and intimate dining options.
Which hotel is nearest to popular landmarks on Shelter Island?
The Pridwin Hotel is just a short walk to Crescent Beach and the Shelter Island Historical Society, making it a convenient choice for visitors.

Other cities in United States

Albany5 properties
Amagansett5 properties
Aquebogue1 properties
Auburn4 properties
Aurora1 properties
Batavia1 properties
Bellport1 properties
Binghamton2 properties
Bohemia1 properties
Bolton Landing1 properties
Brewerton1 properties
Bridgehampton1 properties
Brockport1 properties
Buffalo5 properties
Canandaigua1 properties
Canastota2 properties
Carle Place3 properties
Centereach1 properties
Centerport1 properties
Central Islip1 properties
Chautauqua2 properties
Cheektowaga3 properties
Chestertown2 properties
Cleveland1 properties
Clifton Park1 properties
Commack1 properties
Conesus1 properties
Cooperstown3 properties
Copiague1 properties
Corning2 properties
Cuba1 properties
Diamond Point2 properties
Dunkirk3 properties
Eagle Bay1 properties
East Hampton4 properties
East Norwich1 properties
East Syracuse1 properties
Evans Mills1 properties
Farmingdale2 properties
Farmingville1 properties
Fayetteville1 properties
Fishkill14 properties
Freeport1 properties
Garden City3 properties
Glen Cove1 properties
Glenfield1 properties
Glens Falls2 properties
Grand Island1 properties
Great Neck1 properties
Greenport5 properties
Hamburg1 properties
Hammondsport1 properties
Hampton Bays2 properties
Hauppauge3 properties
Henrietta2 properties
Hopewell Junction1 properties
Horseheads2 properties
Hudson1 properties
Hunter1 properties
Inlet1 properties
Islandia1 properties
Ithaca3 properties
Jay1 properties
Johnson City1 properties
Johnstown1 properties
Lake George21 properties
Lake Luzerne2 properties
Lake Placid3 properties
Latham4 properties
Lawrence1 properties
Liverpool5 properties
Locust Valley1 properties
Long Beach2 properties
Long Lake4 properties
Lynbrook1 properties
Massapequa Park1 properties
Massena3 properties
Medford1 properties
Melville2 properties
Merrick1 properties
Middletown1 properties
Montauk16 properties
Mount Kisco1 properties
Nanuet1 properties
New Hartford1 properties
New Rochelle2 properties
New York3 properties
Newburgh2 properties
Niagara Falls4 properties
North River1 properties
Nyack1 properties
Ocean Beach1 properties
Oneida1 properties
Oneonta1 properties
Oswego2 properties
Paul Smiths1 properties
Plainview3 properties
Plattsburgh6 properties
Port Jefferson1 properties
Poughkeepsie1 properties
Pulaski2 properties
Quogue1 properties
Riverhead5 properties
Rochester14 properties
Rockville Centre2 properties
Rome2 properties
Ronkonkoma5 properties
Roslyn1 properties
Sackets Harbor1 properties
Sag Harbor1 properties
Saugerties2 properties
Schenectady1 properties
Schroon Lake1 properties
Seneca Falls1 properties
Seneca Knolls1 properties
Sidney1 properties
Silver Bay1 properties
Skaneateles1 properties
Southampton6 properties
Southold1 properties
Spackenkill2 properties
Stony Brook2 properties
Syosset1 properties
Syracuse2 properties
Tarrytown4 properties
Ticonderoga1 properties
Tonawanda1 properties
Troy1 properties
Uniondale1 properties
Utica3 properties
Verona3 properties
Wading River1 properties
Wantagh1 properties
Watertown3 properties
Weedsport1 properties
Westbury3 properties
White Plains2 properties
Wilmington1 properties
Woodbury (Nassau County)2 properties
Yonkers2 properties